Scientists at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) have engineered a groundbreaking mineral sunscreen formulation that significantly mitigates the characteristic chalky white residue often associated with these protective products, thereby aiming to bolster daily sun protection adherence across diverse populations. This innovative approach reframes the physical properties of zinc oxide, a key ingredient in mineral sunscreens, to deliver robust ultraviolet (UV) radiation defense without compromising aesthetic appeal. The research, detailed in the journal ACS Materials Letters, holds substantial promise for enhancing skin cancer prevention efforts by making effective sunscreens more palatable and accessible to individuals of all skin tones.
The pervasive recommendation from dermatologists for daily sunscreen application stems from the well-established understanding that excessive exposure to ultraviolet radiation is the foremost preventable factor contributing to skin cancer, which stands as the most prevalent form of cancer diagnosed in the United States. Despite this critical health guidance, a notable segment of the population fails to incorporate sunscreen into their daily routines. A primary impediment frequently cited is the unsightly white or grayish film that traditional mineral sunscreens, particularly those utilizing zinc oxide, can leave on the skin, a phenomenon colloquially known as the "white cast."
This newly developed formulation tackles the "white cast" issue not by introducing novel chemical compounds but by ingeniously modifying the morphology of existing zinc oxide particles. The research team, affiliated with the UCLA Health Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center, successfully synthesized zinc oxide into microscopic, four-armed structures termed tetrapods. These distinctively shaped particles have demonstrated the capacity to provide potent protection against harmful UV rays while exhibiting a markedly reduced tendency to create a visible white film compared to conventionally formulated zinc oxide.
The implications of this development extend beyond mere cosmetic improvement; it addresses a critical barrier to consistent sun protection. "This isn’t just about cosmetics," stated senior author Paul S. Weiss, a distinguished professor at UCLA with extensive expertise in chemistry, bioengineering, and materials science, and an investigator at the Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center. He emphasized that if an improvement in the visual presentation of sunscreen leads to more regular application, the consequences for skin cancer prevention could be profoundly positive.
The potential benefits are particularly salient for individuals with darker skin tones. This demographic often exhibits lower rates of consistent sunscreen use and, consequently, is more prone to receiving a skin cancer diagnosis at later, more advanced stages. While melanoma, the most aggressive form of skin cancer, occurs less frequently in individuals with darker complexions, research indicates a disproportionately higher mortality rate from the disease within these groups. This disparity is frequently attributed to the delayed detection of melanoma, which complicates treatment efficacy.
The genesis of this research for lead author AJ Addae, a UCLA chemical biology doctoral candidate and entrepreneur in cosmetic science, was rooted in personal frustration. "I started thinking about this because I was frustrated by how mineral sunscreen looks on my own skin," Addae shared. His own experiences with the prominent white cast and other aesthetic drawbacks of mineral sunscreens led him to initially forgo sun protection altogether. This personal dissatisfaction served as the crucial impetus for the research endeavor.
Zinc oxide’s widespread adoption in mineral sunscreens is due to its efficacy in blocking both UVA rays, which are implicated in skin aging, and UVB rays, responsible for sunburn and a significant contributor to skin cancer risk. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has affirmed the safety and effectiveness of zinc oxide. Mineral sunscreens are often the preferred choice for individuals with sensitive skin, acne-prone complexions, rosacea, or those seeking alternatives to chemical UV filters.
However, conventional zinc oxide particles tend to aggregate, or clump together, in sunscreen formulations. This clumping can compromise the stability of the product and cause the particles to scatter visible light in a manner that results in the conspicuous white or gray residue, particularly noticeable on darker skin tones. The UCLA team’s investigation focused on whether altering the structural architecture of these particles could inhibit clumping and consequently improve the sunscreen’s visual performance.
Most zinc oxide utilized in sunscreens is composed of exceedingly small, nearly spherical nanoparticles fabricated through standard chemical manufacturing processes. In contrast, the UCLA researchers examined significantly larger particles produced via a proprietary high-temperature flame method, yielding the unique tetrapod shape. "Because of their structure, these tetrapod-shaped particles have standoffs and form porous networks instead of collapsing into clumps," explained Addae. He elaborated that this structural attribute prevents tight packing and aggregation, ensuring uniform dispersion within the sunscreen base.
In comparative analyses, the tetrapod-shaped zinc oxide demonstrated several practical advantages over conventional zinc oxide nanoparticles. When incorporated into sunscreen formulations at equivalent concentrations, the tetrapod-based sunscreens achieved a sun protection factor (SPF) of approximately 30, a level of protection comparable to that offered by standard mineral sunscreens. Furthermore, the lotions containing tetrapod zinc oxide exhibited enhanced stability over time, showing less propensity for separation or thickening.
The most striking improvement was observed in how these novel particles interacted with visible light. Laboratory experiments and controlled applications on human skin revealed that the tetrapod sunscreen possessed a warmer hue that more closely mimicked natural skin tones, effectively eliminating the pronounced white or gray cast typically produced by conventional zinc oxide. This aesthetic enhancement was achieved without the addition of pigments or specialized coatings designed to mask the residue.
"When I spread it on my own skin, I didn’t get that white cast I usually see with zinc oxide," Addae recounted, highlighting the pivotal moment of realization for the project’s potential. Professor Weiss further expressed his surprise at the rapid efficacy of the modification, noting that "The very first formulations already showed a visible difference."
While this promising sunscreen technology necessitates further rigorous testing before it can be brought to market, the researchers underscore its significance in demonstrating how advancements in materials science can surmount practical obstacles in the pursuit of effective skin cancer prevention. "The best sunscreen is the one people will actually use," Addae reiterated. He believes that if zinc oxide can be made to appear more aesthetically pleasing on a wider spectrum of skin tones without sacrificing its protective capabilities, it could empower more individuals to shield themselves from the sun’s most detrimental effects.
The research team is currently engaged in collaborative efforts with the UCLA Health Department of Dermatology, including the UCLA Health’s Skin of Color Clinic. Future research will focus on understanding the interaction of these tetrapod particles with the skin’s microbiome and advancing the technology towards real-world applications. The study was supported in part by grants from the National Science Foundation, the Challenge Initiative at UCLA, and a Sigma Xi IFoRE Grant-in-Aid. Other contributors to the research included Jennifer Uyanga, Professor Justin Carman, and Professor Yogendra Kumar Mishra.
About the Author
