The French Dip sandwich, a beloved culinary staple in the United States, holds a fascinating, distinctly American origin story, despite its misleading moniker. Far from the bistros of Paris, this iconic creation emerged from the bustling eateries of Los Angeles in the early 20th century, sparking a decades-long rivalry between two establishments, each claiming inventorship. The core components of this delectable sandwich typically include thinly sliced, tender beef piled high on a crusty baguette or sub roll, accompanied by a savory beef broth, known as "au jus," for dipping. Often, a slice of melted Swiss cheese further enhances the rich flavor profile. For aficionados seeking a truly substantial experience, where the generous layering of high-quality beef is paramount, a selection of national restaurant chains has distinguished itself by offering exceptional renditions of this classic. This exploration delves into the history, distinct characteristics, and consumer appeal of some of the most satisfying French Dip sandwiches available across the country today.
The exact genesis of the French Dip remains a captivating culinary debate, primarily centered around two Los Angeles institutions: Cole’s Pacific Electric Buffet and Philippe the Original. Cole’s, founded in 1908, posits that its founder, Henry Cole, inadvertently created the sandwich around 1908. The tale suggests that a police officer with sore gums found the hard bread of a traditional sandwich difficult to chew. Cole, seeking to soften the bread, dipped it into the pan drippings from a freshly roasted beef joint. The officer was so delighted that he returned the next day with friends, requesting the "dipped sandwich," thus sparking a trend.
Conversely, Philippe the Original, established in 1908 by Philippe Mathieu, presents its own compelling narrative. Their version dates to 1918, when Mathieu, while preparing a sandwich for a customer, accidentally dropped the French roll into a roasting pan filled with hot beef drippings. The customer, a police officer, was reportedly unperturbed by the mistake and enjoyed the "dipped" sandwich so much that he brought his friends back to try it. Philippe’s also claims to have originated the practice of preparing the sandwich with French bread, a common element today. Regardless of which establishment truly holds the bragging rights, the legacy of both restaurants as pioneers in popularizing this unique sandwich is undeniable, cementing its place in American comfort food history. The "au jus," meaning "with juice" in French, is not merely a condiment but an integral part of the experience, moistening the bread and intensifying the beef’s savory notes.
Among the national chains recognized for their hearty French Dip offerings, Arby’s stands out for its commitment to roast beef, a cornerstone of its brand identity. The chain’s "Classic French Dip & Swiss" embodies its slogan, "We have the meats," by featuring generous portions of its signature slow-roasted beef. This particular sandwich is constructed on a robust sub roll, layered with melted Swiss cheese, and served alongside a cup of warm, flavorful au jus. Arby’s positions this item as a globally inspired delight, humorously stating it encompasses "half the countries in the world on one sandwich." Customer feedback frequently highlights the value and customizable nature of Arby’s French Dip. Diners appreciate the option to use digital coupons, making a high-quality, substantial meal more accessible. The practice of pre-cutting the sandwich in half is also a practical touch, allowing for easier consumption or the convenience of saving a portion for later. Enthusiasts often personalize their order by adding ingredients like red onion and crispy onion strings at no extra charge, demonstrating the chain’s flexibility in catering to individual preferences. Arby’s extensive geographical footprint ensures that this robust French Dip is widely available to a broad consumer base seeking a quick yet satisfying meal.
Shifting to the realm of fast-casual dining, Firehouse Subs presents its own distinctive take on the French Dip, infusing it with Italian-inspired elements. Known for its commitment to supporting first responders and its "steamed to perfection" sub preparation, Firehouse crafts its French Dip using premium roast beef. This is complemented by a medley of caramelized onions, melted provolone cheese, and a sprinkle of Italian seasoning, all nestled within a toasted garlic bread roll. The accompanying hot au jus for dipping ties these rich flavors together. This rendition distinguishes itself through its thoughtful combination of ingredients, moving beyond a simple beef-and-cheese composition. The garlic bread roll adds a pungent, aromatic dimension, while the caramelized onions introduce a subtle sweetness and depth, contrasting with the savory beef and tangy provolone. Customer impressions consistently praise the overall quality and flavor balance. Reviews often commend the soft texture of the bread, the appealing zest of the garlic sauce, and the substantial quantity of both meat and cheese. The quality of the jus is also frequently highlighted, reinforcing its critical role in the sandwich’s appeal. Firehouse Subs’ approach illustrates how a classic can be elevated through distinctive flavor combinations and meticulous preparation, offering a more gourmet experience within a casual setting.
For those seeking a French Dip within a full-service, brewpub atmosphere, BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse offers a "Classic Prime Rib Dip" that has garnered a loyal following. This fan-favorite menu item speaks to BJ’s broader menu strategy, which balances traditional American fare with innovative dishes and a wide selection of craft beers. The sandwich features thinly carved slices of slow-roasted prime rib, a cut of beef renowned for its tenderness and rich flavor, piled generously onto a toasted hoagie roll. To enhance the experience, it is served with a deeply flavorful au jus, a creamy horseradish sauce for an extra kick, coleslaw, and a side of fries. The choice of prime rib elevates this offering significantly, positioning it as a more premium option compared to standard roast beef. The slow-roasting process ensures maximum tenderness and juiciness. The inclusion of creamy horseradish provides a piquant counterpoint to the richness of the beef, while the coleslaw and fries transform the sandwich into a complete, satisfying meal. BJ’s also demonstrates an understanding of modern dietary needs, with customers specifically noting the availability and quality of gluten-free options for their Prime Rib Dip. The ability for patrons to customize their order, such as adding provolone cheese or substituting sides like cheesy mashed potatoes, further underscores the restaurant’s focus on customer satisfaction and culinary flexibility.
Black Bear Diner, with its rustic, comfort-food ethos, offers its "Tri Tip Dip," boldly proclaiming it "A better French dip." This establishment specializes in hearty, homestyle meals, and its Tri Tip Dip fits perfectly within this theme by showcasing a distinct cut of beef. The sandwich features seasoned tri-tip, a triangular cut from the bottom sirloin, known for its robust beefy flavor and relatively lean texture. This is served on a grilled ciabatta roll, offering a chewier texture and a slight char from grilling, differing from the more common baguette or sub rolls. The standard offering comes with au jus, but guests have the option to upgrade to a "deluxe" version, which includes grilled onions, mushrooms, and Swiss cheese, adding layers of savory depth and umami. The use of tri-tip distinguishes Black Bear Diner’s offering from those utilizing prime rib or conventional roast beef, providing a unique flavor and texture profile that appeals to those seeking something a bit different. Customer testimonials frequently laud the quality of the meat, specifically praising its lean composition and absence of excess fat. The crispness of the ciabatta roll and the perfect amount of au jus for dipping are also often highlighted, contributing to an "exceptional" dining experience. This diner’s approach demonstrates how a focus on a specific, high-quality cut of meat and a different bread choice can reimagine a classic.
At the more upscale end of the casual dining spectrum, Hillstone Restaurant Group, known for its Hillstone and Houston’s concepts, offers a "USDA Prime French Dip Au Jus." These restaurants are celebrated for their commitment to premium ingredients, meticulous preparation, and refined dining experiences, and their French Dip exemplifies this philosophy. The sandwich is crafted with thinly sliced, roasted USDA Prime rib, the highest grade of beef available, ensuring exceptional tenderness, marbling, and flavor. This exquisite beef is generously piled onto a toasted French roll and served simply, allowing the quality of the ingredients to shine. Accompaniments typically include a choice of French fries or coleslaw. The "USDA Prime" designation is a significant differentiator, indicating a superior cut of beef that undergoes stringent grading for quality. This choice of prime rib, roasted to perfection, yields a French Dip that is incredibly succulent and rich. Customer reviews often draw parallels between the quality of the au jus and that found in high-end steakhouses, such as the renowned Derby, underscoring the elevated culinary standard. Patrons describe the sandwich as "succulent," even before being lightly dipped into the jus, indicating the inherent flavor and juiciness of the prime rib itself. Hillstone/Houston’s French Dip appeals to a discerning clientele willing to pay a premium for an impeccably prepared classic, showcasing how even a seemingly simple sandwich can be transformed into a gourmet experience through unparalleled ingredient quality and expert execution.
In conclusion, the French Dip sandwich, an enduring American classic with a colorful origin story rooted in Los Angeles, continues to captivate palates across the nation. From fast-food mainstays to casual dining establishments and upscale eateries, each chain brings its unique interpretation to this beloved dish. While the fundamental elements—tender beef, flavorful jus, and a hearty roll—remain constant, the variations in beef cut (from slow-roasted prime rib and tri-tip to classic roast beef), cheese selections, bread choices, and complementary ingredients offer a diverse spectrum of experiences. Whether one prefers the customizable convenience of Arby’s, the Italian-inspired zest of Firehouse Subs, the brewpub comfort of BJ’s Brewhouse, the rustic charm of Black Bear Diner’s tri-tip, or the premium indulgence of Hillstone/Houston’s USDA Prime offering, the common thread is a commitment to providing a satisfying, beef-laden sandwich designed for dipping. These establishments ensure that the tradition of this distinctly American invention continues to thrive, delivering a taste of history with every savory bite.
About the Author
